The Meaningless-ness of Protest: An Urban Pseudo-Leisure

Using recent protest actions in London as a case study, this paper argues the demonstration’s over-normalisation produces a paradox in which urban protest becomes increasingly politically inconsequential. When protest is absorbed into the rhythms of everyday urban life, its capacity to generate meaningful political engagement is diminished, and the perceived effectiveness of collective action is weakened. This phenomenon is compounded by widespread public indifference, limited governmental responsiveness, and a growing sense of frustration and exhaustion among activists, which narrows the discourse of protest itself. These dynamics render protests into a form of alienated pseudo-leisure, rather than a politically disruptive practice. As people march down the street, their collective ‘walk’ is not only the physical act of frustration, but also the reflection of the desired leisure that has yet to exist (Songpetchmongkol & Tam, 2026).

The paper highlights a central dilemma: in contexts where protest is restricted or prohibited, collective mobilisation often carries significant political weight; yet in cities where protest is permitted, routinised, and rendered safe, it risks becoming symbolically hollow. Through the lenses of the recent protest by different groups in London on national identity and immigration, this analysis illustrates how activist movements may become unfulfilling, ineffective, and meaningless when urban conditions erode participation and collective agency, interrogating how political expression is shaped by the structural affordances and limitations of urban life. Through the experimental thought exercise, this paper proposes to imagine a new form of socio-spatial urban setting that would allow protests to be routinised but still remain meaningful and impactful–unsettling protests that actually disrupt the urban landscapes. Essentially, if a protest is indeed the ‘walk’ toward the urban pseudo-leisure, does its meaninglessness still matter? This paper critically pencils the insights that may help future activist movements avoid discursive dead-ends and pursue more impactful avenues for social transformation.

• https://www.urbanstudiesfoundation.org/f...